Back to Insights
Published 19 Nov 2026 Rise Migration Lawyers

Ministerial intervention: what it is and when it’s realistic

A sealed cream envelope resting on a stack of documents beside a fountain pen on a timber desk

When the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) affirms a visa refusal, people are often told their last chance is to ask the Minister to step in. That is still possible, but the rules changed in September 2025. The old test of “unique and exceptional circumstances” has gone, and a request now reaches the Minister only if it fits one of a short list of criteria. Here is how it works and how to tell whether it is realistic for you.

What ministerial intervention is

The Migration Act gives the Minister personal “public interest” powers to replace a tribunal decision with a more favourable one, usually the grant of a visa:

  • Section 351 covers ART decisions on the review of migration and protection decisions.
  • Section 501J covers ART decisions about refusing or cancelling a protection visa.

Only the Minister can use these powers, and the Act says the Minister has no duty even to consider using them. A request is not a visa application, there is no timeframe for an answer, and if the Minister does intervene a statement is tabled in Parliament without your name.

Section 417, the old power for protection decisions, was repealed when the ART replaced the AAT on 14 October 2024. Home Affairs confirms that section 351 can still be used where a section 417 power had been enlivened by an earlier tribunal decision. Other personal powers, such as section 48B (a further protection visa application) and section 195A (a visa for someone in detention), sit outside this process.

What changed in September 2025

On 4 September 2025 the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship issued new Ministerial Instructions for requests under sections 351 and 501J, amended on 17 September 2025. They replaced the Minister’s Guidelines of 11 March 2016. Home Affairs now says the instructions do not allow it to assess “unique or exceptional circumstances”.

On the same day, personal procedural decisions finalised most requests already waiting, apart from cases the Minister was already considering, cases listed in an annexure and certain classes of request. If yours was finalised this way, you can make a new request under the new instructions.

When you can ask

You need a decision from the ART (or, for older cases, the AAT). The power is not available if you never had a tribunal decision, a Minister has already granted you a visa this way, a court has quashed the decision, or the tribunal sent the case back and the Department has made a new decision. You or your authorised representative can make the request, and family members can only be included if they also had a tribunal decision.

How a request is assessed

The Department checks four things, in order, and stops at the first one that fails:

  1. A tribunal decision has enlivened the powers.
  2. The request is properly made: in writing, naming who is included, the power, the tribunal decision and the section 13 criteria relied on, with the evidence.
  3. It is not “inappropriate to refer” under section 12.
  4. It meets at least one section 13 criterion.

Even a referred request can be declined: the Minister may choose not to consider it, or consider it and not grant a visa.

Who can be referred: the section 13 criteria

In short, a request can be referred if you:

  • are the parent of an Australian citizen or permanent resident child who was a minor when the request was made;
  • have the skills for, and currently work in, an occupation on the MLTSSL, STSOL, ROL or CSOL, with a skills assessment or qualification, proof of the work and (if employed) your employer’s support;
  • held a subclass 188 business visa and would now meet the subclass 888 time-in-Australia criteria;
  • care for an Australian citizen with a Carer Visa Assessment Certificate rating of at least 30 who has no other citizen, permanent resident or eligible New Zealand family here and cannot otherwise get care;
  • have a protection finding but were excluded from, refused or had cancelled a protection visa on character grounds;
  • are immediate family of a child found to engage Australia’s protection obligations who holds or held a protection or humanitarian visa;
  • are under 18 and in state or territory welfare care;
  • would meet clause 102.211(2) for an Adoption (subclass 102) visa except for one part of it, and were refused a visa for that reason;
  • came here as a minor, have lived here for at least half your life, have a Commonwealth medical officer’s assessment that return would harm your health, and have no family in any country where you can live; or
  • cannot be returned because your country’s authorities refuse to cooperate.

What rules a request out: section 12

A request is finalised without referral if, for example:

  • you already have an open request, or a Minister personally declined a request about you and you were told less than two years ago;
  • you are unlawful, not in detention, and could apply for a bridging visa but had not when you lodged;
  • you could apply for a Partner visa in Australia but have condition 8503 and had not sought a waiver in the three months before (see our guide to condition 8503 waivers);
  • you have left Australia, or have a visa application, tribunal review or remitted matter still underway;
  • you have a notice of intention to remove, or a Bridging visa E with condition 8512 (leave by a set date); or
  • the request raises only protection (non-refoulement) claims. If you were refused a protection visa before, a section 48B request may be the right step.

Home Affairs adds that if you may be eligible for a Partner visa, that is the pathway to use.

A request does not stop removal

The Minister expects you to stay lawful, engage with the Department and keep making arrangements to leave. Under section 197E of the Act, a request is irrelevant to the Department’s duty to remove an unlawful non-citizen. Removal pauses only once the Minister personally decides to consider your case, and then only for a limited period (six months, unless it ends earlier or you agree in writing to a later date the Minister nominates). In practice that means applying for a Bridging visa E where you can.

So when is it realistic?

Realistic: you clearly fit a section 13 criterion, nothing in section 12 applies, you are lawful, and you can prove it from the start with certified documents and NAATI translations. The Department assesses what you send first.

Not realistic: a request based only on hardship, community ties or years in Australia, a request made while another pathway such as a partner visa is open, or one made after you leave. Check your other options first in our guides to options after a refusal and judicial review after an ART decision: the 35-day court deadline keeps running while you think about a request.

Frequently asked questions

Can I still ask the Minister to use section 417?

No. Section 417 was repealed when the ART started on 14 October 2024. If your case had a section 417 power through an earlier tribunal decision, the request is now made under section 351.

Does a ministerial intervention request let me stay in Australia?

Not by itself. It is not a visa application, and removal can go ahead unless the Minister has decided to consider your case. You need to hold a valid visa, usually a bridging visa, while the request is assessed.

Can I ask before the ART decides my review?

No. The power only exists once there is a tribunal decision, and a request made while a review is still underway is finalised without referral.

The Minister said no before. Can I ask again?

If the Minister personally declined and you were told less than two years ago, a new request is treated as a repeat request and is not referred. If your earlier request was finalised by the September 2025 procedural decisions, Home Affairs says you can make a new request.

How do I make a request?

In writing, through the Contact the Minister online form or by post to the Minister at Parliament House. Name the power, the tribunal decision and the section 13 criteria you rely on, and attach certified evidence. Do not send USBs or CDs: Home Affairs returns them unread.

Talk to Rise before you lodge

A request that does not fit the instructions is finalised without reaching the Minister, and if a request does reach the Minister and is declined, a new one will not be referred for two years. A Rise lawyer can check whether you meet a section 13 criterion, whether anything in section 12 rules you out, how to keep you lawful in the meantime, and whether another pathway is stronger. Book a consultation, or read more on our ministerial intervention and ART appeals pages.

Sources

Talk to a lawyer

Unsure how this affects your matter?

Migration rules change quickly. Speak with an Australian immigration lawyer about how the current settings apply to your circumstances before you lodge.

Book Consultation →