Back to Insights
Published 17 Nov 2026 Rise Migration Lawyers

Judicial review after an ART decision: when it’s worth considering

Stack of law books and an open bound document on a timber desk

When the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) affirms a visa refusal, the usual next question is whether you can appeal. For most people the answer is judicial review in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2). It can be the right step, but only in a particular kind of case, and the decision has to be made quickly. This guide explains when judicial review is realistically worth considering, and when your time and money may be better spent elsewhere.

If your refusal has not been to the ART yet, start with our guides My visa was refused: what are my options? and Applying to the ART: lodging to hearing. The ART is usually the better place to argue about facts and evidence.

Judicial review is not a second hearing

The court does not decide whether you should get the visa. The Federal Circuit and Family Court explains that the judge can only review the decision to see whether a “jurisdictional error” was made: whether the decision-maker made the decision properly, followed the correct legal procedures and applied the law correctly.

ART merits review Judicial review in court
The question What is the correct or preferable decision on the facts? Was the decision made according to law?
New evidence Yes, the ART looks at the case afresh Not new facts, unless they go to whether there was a legal error
Can it grant the visa? It can set aside the decision and substitute a new one, or send it back No. It can send the case back to be decided again
If you lose You have paid the ART fee You will usually pay the Minister’s legal costs

That is why judicial review suits some cases and not others. A decision can feel harsh, or weigh the evidence differently from how you would, and still be lawful.

The 35-day time limit, and when it starts

Under section 477 of the Migration Act, an application to the Federal Circuit and Family Court must be made within 35 days of the date of the migration decision. For an ART migration review, that date is the day the decision is taken to have been made: the day the Tribunal makes its written statement, or the day it gives the decision orally at the hearing.

That is often earlier than the day you read it. The ART has up to 14 days after that date to send you the written decision (section 368A), so part of your 35 days may already be gone when the letter arrives. The court itself warns that the date of the decision may be different from the date on your letter.

The court can extend the 35 days, but only if you apply in writing explaining why, and it is satisfied an extension is necessary in the interests of the administration of justice. There is no appeal from an order granting or refusing that extension. Treat day 35 as the real deadline.

Which court?

  • Federal Circuit and Family Court (Division 2): most reviews of ART migration and protection decisions.
  • Federal Court: ART decisions on character reviews under section 500, and character decisions made personally by the Minister (for example under section 501 or 501CA). The same 35-day limit applies under section 477A.

When judicial review is worth considering

An honest assessment usually comes down to four questions.

1. Is there a real legal error in the reasons?

The starting point is the ART’s written reasons, not your sense that the result is unfair. Examples of the kind of error a court can look at include:

  • Unfair procedure required by the Act. For example, section 359A requires the ART to give you clear particulars of information that would be the reason, or part of the reason, for affirming the refusal, and invite you to comment. If it relied on such information without doing that, there may be an arguable error.
  • The wrong legal test. The member misread a provision, or applied criteria your visa did not actually have to meet.
  • A claim or key evidence ignored. Something clearly put to the Tribunal was not dealt with at all, not merely given less weight than you wanted.
  • A finding that was not lawfully open. In limited cases, reasoning can be so unreasonable or illogical that it crosses the line. This is a high bar.

If the honest complaint is “the member did not believe me” or “I now have better evidence”, the court is generally not the place to fix it.

2. What would winning actually achieve?

If the judge finds a jurisdictional error, the court can send your case back to the decision-maker and stop the Minister acting on the decision. In practice that usually means the ART decides your review again, according to law. It can still refuse. Judicial review is most valuable where, once the error is corrected, you have a genuine case on the merits, for example because you clearly met the criterion the Tribunal got wrong.

3. Can you carry the cost and the risk?

The court’s filing fee for a migration application is $4,180, or $2,090 if a Registrar decides you may pay a reduced fee, and another fee is payable before the final hearing (fees from 1 July 2026). Some people with concession cards or in financial hardship may be exempt. The bigger risk is costs. The court says that if your application is dismissed, or you discontinue it, you will have to pay the Minister’s legal costs. Its published scale for migration matters ranges from about $1,821 for a case that ends at or before the first court date to about $9,098 for one decided at a final hearing, and stopping early generally costs less.

The law also screens out weak cases. Under section 486I, a lawyer cannot file a migration case unless they certify in writing that there are reasonable grounds for believing it has a reasonable prospect of success, and section 486E lets the court order costs against anyone who encourages litigation with no reasonable prospect. A careful “no” from a lawyer is part of the system working.

4. Is another option stronger?

Sometimes a fresh visa application, or a request for ministerial intervention, is the better route. If you are in Australia, check first whether the section 48 bar limits what you can apply for.

Staying lawful while the court decides

Filing in court does not, by itself, keep you lawful. Home Affairs says that if a merits review tribunal upholds the refusal and you apply for judicial review, you need to apply for a bridging visa to stay lawful during the proceedings, and you can only apply by webform. A Bridging visa A granted on or after 19 November 2016 generally ceases 35 days after the Tribunal’s decision, and a bridging visa linked to judicial review generally ceases 28 days after a court upholds the refusal or you withdraw. Check VEVO for your own dates and read our bridging visas guide.

What to do now

  1. Work out the date the ART decision was made, not the date you received it, and count 35 days from there.
  2. Get the full written decision and reasons, and keep everything you gave the Tribunal.
  3. Check your bridging visa in VEVO.
  4. Get advice early. A lawyer needs time to read the reasons and, if there is a real error, to prepare the application and grounds before day 35.

For the court process itself, including service on the Minister and the documents involved, see our guide to judicial review of a migration decision.

Frequently asked questions

Can I give the court new evidence that I did not give the ART?

Generally no. The court does not reconsider the facts and can only take new factual information into account if it is relevant to whether the decision-maker made a jurisdictional error. If your case depends on new evidence, a fresh application or another option may suit you better.

I received the ART decision two weeks after it was made. Do I still have 35 days?

No. The 35 days run from the date the decision was made, which for an ART migration review is the day of the written statement or the oral decision, so in that example about 21 days would be left. The court can extend time only where it is necessary in the interests of the administration of justice, so act straight away.

If I win, do I get the visa?

No. The court cannot grant a visa. If it finds a jurisdictional error, it can send the case back to be decided again and stop the Minister acting on the flawed decision. The ART then decides your review again, and the outcome is not guaranteed.

What happens if I lose?

The refusal stands, and you will usually have to pay the Minister’s legal costs under the court’s scale. A bridging visa linked to the court case generally ends 28 days after the court upholds the refusal, so plan your next step before the hearing.

Can I apply to the court without a lawyer?

Yes, you can represent yourself, but the court recommends getting legal advice before you apply. The grounds must identify a specific legal error, and the costs risk is real, so an early assessment of the reasons is worth having.

Talk to Rise before day 35

Send us the ART decision and its reasons. A lawyer will read them, check them against the law, and tell you plainly whether there is an arguable legal error, what a win would realistically achieve, and what it would cost. If there is not a case, we will say so and talk you through the alternatives. Book a consultation or see our judicial review and ART appeals pages.

Sources

Talk to a lawyer

Unsure how this affects your matter?

Migration rules change quickly. Speak with an Australian immigration lawyer about how the current settings apply to your circumstances before you lodge.

Book Consultation →